I have had two Garmin Streetpilots and I was so fed up with the last one that I threw it away a few weeks ago. It was anything EXCEPT Garmin, for obvious reasons. I do not tolerate any blinking/flashing/scrolling/etc. on displays so I went to Circuit City to check out what they have. The Garmins and the Sonys were inaccessible whereas this Mio was accessible. First impression is that the unit is of cheap quality. Second impression, the same. The Garmin is built like the proverbially brick sh**house. It is ( almost ) indestructible ( the thrown away unit tolerated an amazing amount of physical abuse as I decommissioned it prior to the trash heap ). The Mio looks like it will shatter if it falls off of the windshield. ( it does fall off of the windshield, repeatedly; but it is still in one piece ) This is a small unit ( maybe 25% the volume of the Garmin ). It has a HUGE cigarette lighter plug. It is so large and bulky that it gets in the way of the gearshift. You would think that this plug was designed for a welding machine, not a GPS unit? The Garmins come with a very nice bean bag mount. ( the unit clips to the bean bag and you position the bean bag on the dashboard ). The Mio has a mickey-mouse suction cup mount that is worthless. After cleaning the windshield, etc. it was only with a lot of effort that the Mio would remain in place without falling off ( comment: in my state windshield mounts are illegal. thanks, Mio. second, it doesn't attach to dashboard ). Since GPS units are designed to be stolen, it is necessary to remove ( and hide ) the Mio whenever you get out of your car. This means that you have to remove it from the windshield. Then, of course, you have to go through the unecstatic agony of trying to reattach it. ( I have to use the glue to the windshield base to even get it to stay attached at all ). All in all, this is just a total pain in the rear end. Unit takes a while to acquire satellites. Once, after initial acquisition, unit display comes up immediately without the long delays of Garmin units ( gps position may be incorrect until a new fix is obtained ). Options and features are limited. Menus are quite straightforward, however, and very easy to use. ( no manual ). Response to menu entries is somewhat slow. You can select from a qwerty style keypad or an a-z keypad which is nice. Address entry is relatively straightforward although the unit lists every street in the state that matches the street you enter. ( armageddon way, las vegas, nv; armageddon way, reno; etc so you pick street and city from list matching name ). There is no blinking cursor as there is with the Sony units. After you select the street/city, a very easy to use numeric keypad with BIG keys comes up and you enter the street number. You then select the address from a list, preview it, and then go to it ( routing ). Database searching for street addresses and routing calculations are relatively painless. There are no idiot animations, etc. ( the garmins have these and that is why I gave up on them. as well as bugs, bugs and bugs ) Another reviewer said that this unit gives clear directions? That was definitely NOT by experience. Garmins typically have a speeth imphediment and this unit does, too; only much worse. Pronunciations are often grossly incorrect or incomprehensible. It is often difficult to understand them when you are driving. The Garmins are very predictable about advance turn notification ( say 30-60 seconds in advance contingent upon how fast you are driving ); the Mio is somewhat unpredictable. With the Garmin, you can rely exclusively on the voice directions; with the Mio, the voice directions are inadequate and you have to look at the screen display, too. The main advantage of the Garmin StreetPilots is that they have the "speak" button. You push it and it repeats the directions. That is perfect for a brain dead idiot like me who forgets the directions five seconds after I hear them. The Garmin units ( which have MAJOR bugs in the routing software ) generally route better. The Mio repeatedly misrouted me and chose obscure routes. One time, it did not recognize that a road had been blocked. ( ie: to prevent through traffic; this was an old blockage so this should not have been a problem. sometimes Garmins do NOT recognize dead end roads and route you off the freeway down the embankment or other dangerous maneuvers. ( this is why I through away the StreetPilot - it was too unreliable and it let me down all too many times ). I was suprised that the Mio showed some very rural, not really roads ( more like driveways to multiple residences ). I was not routing then so I don't know if the Mio would misroute me out into the poppies the way Garmin units do. ( you have to be very careful with the Garmin units; misrouting onto dirt/dead end/ incorrect roads is very common. another reason I threw the Garmin away ) The Mio is little more than an entry level - trainer GPS. I have no choice so I have to use it. If you have a choice, look somewhere else, maybe. GPS units definitely need to be tried in the store so you can understand the interface. Unfortunately, you have to drive 500-1000 miles in urban, suburban and rural environments to properly evaluate them. Then, it has been too long to return the unit if it is not acceptable. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 6 |
|
|