| Products Electronics & Photo Cameras Canon XH A1 | Satisfaction | Experience | |
|---|
| Name | Date | Helpfulness | Review | Overall satisfaction | Ease of use | Quality of Manufacture | Durability | more... |
|
|---|
| Amazon.com customer | 2008-10-24 | | OUTSTANDING PICTURE | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | GREAT CAMERA!! THE PICTURE IS OUTSTANDING!! ONE DISAPPOINTMENT IS THAT THE CAMERA IS NOT EQUIPMENT WITH A "HDMI" CABLE CONNECTION. FOR THE PRICE I WAS SURE THAT IT WOULD HAVE THAT CONNECTION. BUT OVERALL, I'M VERY HAPPY WITH THE CAMERA. 99% OF MY SHOOTING IS OUTSIDE OF ACTIVE RAILROAD OPERATIONS. FAST MOVING TRAINS, ETC. ASO I SHOOT FIREFIGHTING SCENES FOR MY FIRE DEPT. ONCE AGAIN, OUTSTANDING CAMERA!!
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-10-23 | | Great camera | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Having worked with many 'prosumer' 3CCD cameras, this is a great choice for an aspiring filmmaker of any sort. I use it for films, video journalism, blogging, anything. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-09-20 | | warning! Be careful with compatibility | 4 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | All Canon HDV cameras has an important issue: if you record in 24F or 30F modes, the tapes can only be played back in the camera itself. Canon records those signals in a proprietary mode that is not HDV compliant. YOU CANNOT PLAYBACK THE TAPES IN ANY DECK OR CAMERA other than Canon. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 4 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-09-14 | | Great Price for a Great Camera | 8 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | <a href="http://www.amazon.com/review/R3806EH8COQTFY">Watch Video Here: http://www.amazon.com/review/R3806EH8COQTFY</a> Thinking of moving to HD? It's probably a good time to do it! Canon XH A1 1.67MP 3CCD High-Definition Camcorder with 20x Optical Zoom Focus Enhancements 60GB FireStore FS-4 Pro HD DV Disk Recorder With Direct To Edit DTE Technology - Model ASYF-1162-01LF Miscellaneous Accessories | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 8 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-09-08 | | A occasional fuzzy image problem shooting in standard definition | 2 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | If you get an earlier version of the XH-A1 you may experience a problem shooting in standard definition. (It only occurs in some, not all cameras.) Your picture will look fine in your viewfinder and on your LCD screen. However when you download the footage the scene will be out of focus and the central image will look fuzzy (i.e. something other than the central image may be in sharp focus)--check this using a tripod for the shoot. It will be more pronounced if you are using a wide aperture. This only occurs if you shoot in standard definition and not while you are shooting in HD. (My guess is the problem is an adjustment for SD auto focus with the HD lens.) This is a problem Canon will fix for you in a very quick turn around. If you think this is occurring with your XH-A1 you should call Canon tech support and go over the problem with them so they can give you a repair code. Most likely the repair will be free. If you have this problem, once they repair it, this will be, once again, a five star camcorder. This camera is so complex you might not know whether any problem you are having is you or the camera, so I just wanted to mention this case where the problem does seem to be the camera's. 2008 Learn the (Canon XH A1, XH-A1) XHA1 TUTORIAL TEACHING PROGRAMMED-INSTRUCTION DVD | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 2 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-08-28 | | I'm baffled! Amazing camera! | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | So with pretty much a whole year in research and reading forums,reviews, watching test footage, and more I was stuck on every question any film or video enthusiast comes across. "What camera do i buy?" To be honest...i was sold on the HVX200. I couldn't believe how good it looked and all the frame rates and recording on cards! Kicked the crap out of minidv tapes right?! Well, i got my hands on the hvx200 and found out the hype didn't live to my expectations. Too much grain, expensive P2, too bulky (personally), the menus were like a labyrinth, and i just didn't like it. It's a good cam don't get me wrong but not my choice. Now i was previously a HV20 owner (still am) and am very pleased with Canon. I've been eying the XH-A1 for a while too and read so many reviews and watched some much footage that made it look absolutely amazing! I love Canon and trusted my extinct...Just received this monster today! Seriously a gorgeous design, sleek black, amazing footage, not a consumer camera but when your familiar with pro cameras this was very easy going to me but still had some curves to learn. The footage looked just as good as the HVX, i think. To my eye i like the look of the XH-A1 100X better with color adjustments in camera of course. Overall, this camera was probably the best investment for my budget. I would highly highly recommend this to any indie filmmaker, documentarian, videographer, or any serious film person. This camera lived beyond it's expectation from me. I mean a camera half the price of one of the best camera's on the market (HVX200) and looks just as good as it does, why wouldn't you choose it?! This is my personal view on it. I could go on about the features about the camera but there is too many good things about this camera. Only negative is i wish it had more shutter speeds. But all in all, best camera i have ever used and the only camera i will need for the next 5 years until Red develops the Scarlet to truly be $3k and under. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-08-11 | | How to reduce noise in stills | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I think this is a great camera. I don't have anything to add to what others have said about its video performance, but can share some advice about getting the best stills. I use the camera for photographing orchestral performances, and value it for its silent shutter when making stills. First, set the recording device to tape, even though you're recording the stills to the SD card. When the recording device is set to card, the camera has an annoying (to the photographer and to the musicians) fake shutter sound. Second, turn off AGC and set gain to 0; that will keep the noise down. Turn on the zebras, set the trigger level to 95, and give it as much exposure as you can without blowing important highlights. You can use the lens wide open at the shorter focal lengths, but stop down a stop at the longest, if there's enough light. Used this way, you'll get good mid-tones, and minimal noise in the shadows.
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-08-07 | | Great for Run and Gun Videography | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | While the XH A1 does have its drawbacks (4:2:0 color space of HDV, etc), the price, light sensitivity, great picture quality, and light weight more than make up for them. I use the camera on a daily basis filming run and gun "man on the street" style interviews and sequences and I couldn't be happier with the choice. While a tapeless workflow is being touted as the future, and no doubt is, there's something nice about being able to label and file away your original tapes and rest assured that your footage is backed up regardless of what happens on the workstation. Highly recommend this camera over the competition in this relative price arena, especially for individuals who do a lot of run and gun with only available light. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-07-07 | | One of the best Prosumer cams | 8 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I own it. I use it a lot. 9 months now and it's still working fine. No drop outs on the tapes and I've put it through some challenging climates as well as racking up significant hours shooting and digitizing. I like that it shoots tape, as that's what my clients demand from me (it's the reason I had to buy this particular HDV cam in the first place) and I can buy stock anywhere in the world (and have). However, with the cost of digital storage these days, the cams that offer recording field footage on advanced flash cards start looking like a really nice option as it bypasses the issue of tape mechanism breakdown as the hours usage starts to add up. My first week of shooting with this cam in Beijing I suffered through a chinese dude stumbling into my gear and basically sitting on my XH. The mic broke right off. It's not attached with a sturdy mount, just internal plastic with a lot of play, so if you're doing extensive run and gun you might want to consider that. It sticks out there and is vulnerable. I use an external shotgun anyway, so while I was sad to see the mic break off, it doesn't affect my work. I don't really like the image chip presets/defaults on the camera, very bland, but they're easily changed and one can do endless tweaks for the settings that work best for you and your style. I do a fair amount of work for live music acts, and the ability of this camera to counter-balance the heavy red light typical of live venues has been a blessing. Also, there are plenty of users out there that share their chip settings and downloading them from the net and putting them on your own XH A1 is pretty easy. Many many things are user programmable on this camera. Color settings, gain settings, focal ring sensitivity, zoom speed, etc. I use the camera exclusively in manual mode, so these controls are ideal. I find that editing HDV on my FCP system has been almost as fluid as my DV projects. It's ever so slightly bogged down by the necessity to do on-the-fly time-code calculations due to the nature of the codec, but it's very negligible. In fact, because of HDV, FCP defaults to a nice real-time capture process that I like --where it grabs clips individually rather than consolidated (as on DV). So that's a nice bonus! As far as the limitations of HDV, Yes, they exist. Big deal. I don't understand the logic of folks that bash the codec/format. If you don't know what the HDV format is all about, then chances are you're not shooting as a true pro, and you're working the middle ground in some way (and there's lots of work in that part of the market) so what's the worry? The color sampling is highly compressed. Yeah? And if you were doing a real shoot that required serious green-screen or some such, something tells me you'd have the budget for gear north of 3k. Sheesh. Otherwise, your gonna get a cam that has the capability of creating really nice motion picture images that's ridiculously affordable. And, if you're an aspiring pro or a motivated enthusiast, you're going to find that your skills and ambitions will allow you to push this camera to really high levels of image quality. Basically if you know what you're doing the camera will deliver. Keep in mind that ANY camera in the same budget can and will accomplish the same. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 8 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-04-23 | | XH A1 HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!! | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Since the purchase of this excellent camera We have been able to capture some of the greatest hunting footage my team has ever experienced. Camera has performed flawlessly in 30 degree weather and up. Beginners can pick this camera and be filming in no time at all! Some of the highly detailed settings are complicated but the auto mode eliminates the guess work on them. Fitting it in my budget to purchase TWO more of these by september. Will never use anything but a canon. Got an eight year old XL1 that performs just like a new one! What are you waiting for? ORDER ONE NOW!!!!! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-02-22 | | The Camera is Perfect for an Independent Student Filmmaker (like me!) | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Basically this camera is everything its cracked up to be and more. I bought it purely for the image quality (1.67 Million pixels per CCD, compared to Panasonic's 554k per CCD for the HVX) and the 24f/p "film look." I have not been disappointed. Firstly, the resolution is a huge improvement compared to regular DV. It gives you instant credibility and professionalism over other films shot on regular DV. You're also operating at 18.5 mbps during playback, which is far greater than DV. You've got a lot more to tweak, color correct, and work with. The lens on this camera is also a amazing, go out and take some night shots with it, you'll be amazed. Basically, film people like to talk a lot about the limitations of HDV and the compression etc. And rightfully so, it's a pain to realize that you're not getting exactly what you're shooting but compressed GOPs. But honestly, if you watch a short film on DVD that's been shot on the uncompressed Panasonic HVX and then watch one that's been shot on the Canon HX A1- they're going to look very similar if not indecipherable. (if the DP knows what they're doing). Ultimately this camera provides 95% of the look of what a professional camera, or in my case the HVX, does. I'm really not willing to shell out the extra 2 to 4 thousand to increase a few percentage points. Also, I think people, filmmakers in particular, tend to forget that audiences don't watch films for the amazing uncompressed footage but for the strong characters and compelling narrative. So far with the XH A1 I've shot two HD films that have gone on to screen at festivals. When the image is on the big screen, it looks great. I am very proud of my work and that I own such a nice piece of equipment to shoot my films with. It is also loaded with an incredible amount of options and features- which is a bonus. On a side note, the idea of P2 workflow is amazing to me, but I simply can't afford it. I've also heard the HX A1 works with a drag and drop Firestore hard drive that's only $400. This offers the same simple workflow at a fraction of the cost. : ) I'll put it on my list. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-02-15 | | so far so good. | 8 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I chose this camera for the HD function and the manual rings around the lens, not to mention it seems to be the best deal for the money. For the record this is my first serious camcorder, and I am currently in film school so I already have a good understanding of how a camera (film or digital) works. For the HD remember that it's not "true" HD it's Canon's answer to it. I haven't finished a project in the HD function so I can't rate how close it comes to true HD, although I bet I won't find a difference with my naked eyes. The manual focus/iris/and zoom rings are great for small and precise control, but lag quite a bit when you really want a fast and smooth transition. You just loose that feeling of complete control when you really want to crank it for a quick zoom or focus change. Still the great amount of control built into the camera is great and fairly intuitive to use, and being able to save multiple presets with almost every option is great. Also for those looking for a camera that works with multiple lenses(like a fisheye maybe???), keep looking. End of the day, I'm very happy with my purchase. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 8 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-02-10 | | Best HDV Camera in it's class. | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | This thing is awesome, full of options, plenty of features, and built solid. It's certainly the best camera in it's class. Easily accessible settings, quality glass, 20x zoom. Perhaps perfection if they would've designed it to be able to zoom and adjust the focus simultaneously, and had more of a matte box lens hood like the sony's. Great camera. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2008-01-15 | | AMAZING Camera! | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I've worked with a Panasonic AG-DVX100B and several consumer cameras both HD and SD. I can without any doubt in my mind say that if you are willing to commit several weeks to learning the ins and outs of this camera; you will not get better visual images from anything under 8k. The customization feature of the A1 are worth 3k alone. You can match this camera to anything out there, including film. The A1 carries Cannon's L series lens which gives sharp images even at the end of its 20x range. The images produced are crisp, clear, HD and completely stunning. Watching random footage from the A1 on a 67" HDTV is pure eye-candy! Unless you are looking for a camera with the more expensive flash media capabilities, or dozens of variable frame-rates, this is the camera for you! I have used this camera for close to a year now. Here are several things you must know before you buy: 1. "True HD" is something to discuss for those who study lines and pixels. Those of us who make stunning visual images worry about such things as lighting, composition, movement, audio, etc. This camera has enough resolution to produce amazing results even in not-so-stunning situations. 2. HDV is the most practical "HD" codec out there. It allows you to record to cheap tapes and when you wish to edit, you are able to do so on your computer. No need for fancy editing consoles, tape decks, and expensive flash media. 3. Stop reading reviews and go look at some of the work that's been done with the A1. - Search for "Steven Dempsey" on vimeo.com All of his recent work is done with the A1 - http://www.dvinfo.net/conf/forumdisplay.php?f=143 is a community of filmmakers who use the A1. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2007-12-24 | | Little champ | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I purchased the Canon XH A1 for a specific project. I received the camera only 1 night before the first day of shooting was scheduled. Be sure to read through the manual to learn what this thing can do. I usually don't read manuals but the custom color/contrast settings are a bit advanced and very helpful in getting the 'look' you want. I have only been impressed with this camera (as I often am with any Canon products). Battery conservation is excellent, audio is crisp, custom options abound, manual controls are easily accessible, low-light situations are not a problem (+6 to +32 gain! use sparingly, of course), and the image is fantastic for HDV. Some people have been complaining about the smaller LCD flip-out monitor. I have not found this to be a problem thanks to Canon's focus assist features (2x magnify and the high-contrast mode). I have one very small complaint: make the MIC->XLR switch a hardware switch! It's annoying to switch it in the camera menu. All the other audio control switches are hardware, so why not that? Overall, this is a 5-star product at a very reasonable price. 24f, 30f, and 60i modes all perform beautifully. If you're looking for the right hardcase, I have been very pleased with the Pelican 1550 Case w/Foam (Black) | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2007-12-14 | | Best Camera, Best Price | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Ok may not be the best camera out there, but anything better will set you back a few extra grand. This will give you the best image out of any HDV or 1/3 inch ccd out there - you can step up to the advanced Canon HD models, but those are mostly the same image with more control features and an 8K price tag. By far the best bang for buck that ever existed LOL - even Canon's HV20 held up pretty well to other HD 3 chip cameras. For the cons, main sticking point is that the zoom/focus rings are a tad slow, but for some people this is an advantage - frankly I loved the lightning fast rings on the DVX/HVXs by Panasonic which were great for developing multi shot action for documentaries. Another con is the focus distance is longer than your standard camera - you'll have to stand 5-10 feet further from the subject than normal if your indoors. But overall, as annoying as these gripes are personally, you still can't find a better image from any other HDV camera. And you can't find a better price either - sure there's cheaper HD 3 chip cameras out there made by Sony mostly, but the quality is a HUGE drop off, so this is the lowest price you'll get for a truly top notch product. I've shot stuff side by side for events with a Sony Z1U, which is at least 1000 more and the Canon had deeper and more accurate color, very noticeably sharper image, and less color drop off in low light. Plus having an iris ring vs. a tiny scroll wheel that other camera's have is a big plus. Don't worry about the 24F (some are worried over the difference between 24f and 24P) - you cannot TELL a difference at all - I zoomed into a frame to see if I could pick up on any differences - nada. Just a razor sharp image. The difference is the algorithms Canon uses to compress the footage onto tape vs. 24p - to make a long story short, hence the F and not P in descriptions, but it is certainly not a drop off. And to clarify something, this does up to -36 db of grain - I saw a few articles / reviews on the net saying it can only do -12. By default the gain settings are -6,-12, but you can change that in the menu to go higher if you need. Even though grain is never wanted, if you're stuck in that situation, the grain on this camera actually does resemble film grain moreso than video grain, so if you do get caught in low light, it's not that big of a deal so long as you're not in pitch darkness, it kind of adds to the film look in 24F mode. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2007-12-02 | | Go with Canon XH A1 | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I bought Canon XH A1 a few weeks ago. I have used it under different light and space settings and I want to say that is a very good camera. It has several menus that you need to try and a few things to remember, but the overall conclussion is that not only it produces good video but also it teaches you the basics on filming. For a novice in video production like me it is a good tool to achieve professionalism. I -as many more have done- spent a lot of time comparing models, reading reviews and testimonies. Finally I decided for Canon XH A1 and so far I am very motivated to continue with this one. If you have questions about this review, please write to my email: libnysr@felpsis.net | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2007-11-30 | | Great Pro Camera | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | This is a top of the line Broadcast Quality Camcorder. It records on tape or chip, and has a bewildering array of buttons and switches. But with enough study, you can turn out professional HI-DEF videos; including wide-screen 16X9. My main complaint, and this is a BIG one, is it is VERY hard to setup the Firewire feed to a computer. For some reason your Video editing program can't see this camera unless ALL other imaging equipment is either deleted or disabled. That includes any other Video feeds, such as TV Tuners, Scanners, etc. I have spent over a week trying, and STILL do not have it feeding the Firewire line. But I am working on it, and welcome any suggestions from ANYBODY! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2007-11-24 | | HDV is only good for cost conscious shooters | 6 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | HDV is only a way to get near-HD recording for cheap. If cost is more important than image quality, then HDV is the way to go. This camera claims "True 1080" resolution. Unfortunately, that's a marketing term that is meaningless. No HDV camera can capture true HD 1080 resolution on tape which is defined as 1920x1080 pixels. The HDV format is limited to 1440x1080 and ultra-crummy 4:2:0 color sampling. Plus HDV's MPEG-2 codec is notoriously funky to edit with. You are missing about 25% of horizontal pixels with HDV compared to real HD. I would not recommend HDV if you plan to do any chroma keying, visual effects (compositing) or extensive post effects (like Magic Bullet). If you need to do these things, I would only recommend an HDV camcorder that has uncompressed HDMI output paired with an Intensity Pro card for capture. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 6 |
|
| | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2007-11-23 | | Worth the time to learn | 10 | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | The canon is not your average point and shoot video camera. Although your results will likely be great if you're outside shooting your child's sports event, the camera requires patience and frequent use to get a feel for it's abilities. The best recommendation I can make to folks looking to purchase this camera is to shoot often, shoot in low light, bright light, get a feel for what the built-in Neutral Density filter does for you, and how to use the audio controls. It's taken me about 6-8 hours of filming in 15 minute intervals to get my comfort level up to a point where I'm happy and excited to shoot important events. This is a fantastic professional camera and while the average user won't need to worry about customizing all the color settings (although there programs to help you), the professional will love the control settings, the user defined program buttons, and the timecoding found in the sister camera, the XH-G1. Have fun, this is a great camera. -------- Why I chose this camera over it's rivals: 1. 3CCD means (at the time I purchased) a better low light film quality. 2. External XLR audio. I tend to prefer the audio from a shotgun mic, or the wind filtering fuzzies on a shure mic. 3. Flip out LCD. This is a must for comfortable shooting / tripod shooting. 4. Handle controls. Shoot those low shots aiming up with comfort without getting off the stage. 5. Tapes. SD cards are great, but I tend to shoot once and keep the tapes forever, so SD cards were an expensive option for shoot once storage (they're cheaper now, but i still feel kinda silly not re-using memory cards). Importing onto my mac is a piece of cake. PC users may need some special software. Have fun and happy shooting! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | |
| |