| | Satisfaction | Experience | |
|---|
| Name | Date | Helpfulness | Review | Overall satisfaction | Ease of use | Quality of Manufacture | Durability | Meets Expectations | more... |
|
|---|
| Amazon.com customer | 2006-12-31 | | A Year Review | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Well, it has been a year since I recieved my Rebel XT and I am more than pleased with the camera. The build quality, features, and photo quality have made this camera a joy to own and use. When I first decided to move from film to digital, I began the long and tedious process of researching all the cameras on the market at the time. I had previously owned many Canon film cameras and compact digital cameras, so they were of course my first choice. I looked at Nikon, Olympus, Canon, and Konica(now Sony) dSLR's. The Canon came out on top in all catergories with the exception of a few at the time, such as price because of the Nikon D50, though the Rebel's other features clearly outway the Nikon. Overall, the Canon is just a superior camera, so hopefully, that saves you the trouble of spending nearly a month researching. Alright, so how is that camera? It is wonderful. It fits well in my hands and everything is where it should be. It does feel a little light, but it is made to be compact and light, plus that can easily be remidied by adding a battery grip. All of it's settings and features are virtually identical to the more expensive 20D, as is the image quality. There is a good amount of grain at ISO 1600, which is really a shame, but that can generally be fixed in an image editing program or by using a flash. The battery life is very good, but I do reccomend purchasing that battery grip that I mentioned before. Not only does it add weight and balance the camera, but it also doubles the battery life, which is good for those of us who go out and take thousands of pictures. This is just a wonderful camera for the prosumer crowd, and there is no reason that it cannot be used as a pro camera for creating prints and such. I would recomend this to anyone looking to break into photography or someone who has been photographing for 30 years. My recomendations: - Get a few extra batteries and a battery grip. Remember, you don't have to buy a Canon grip or batteries, and if you don't, you'll probably save at least 50%. Do some research on here. The Opteka grip is great, it is what I own, and you can find a huge number of batteries, just pick own with a good review. - Sigma lenses are generally in expensive, take great shots, and are durable. Some Canon lenses will have better optics, but will cost at least twice as much. - Get the Canon 50mm f/1.8. It is a very inexpensive lens(about $60 - $70) and takes amazing shots. - Big memory cards are amazing. Buy one, seriously. I have a 6GB card and shoot in RAW, so I get about 650 pictures. JPG will get 2000. I need another one because I shoot so much. - External hard drives are a must for all those big files. I have a 250GB Phantom Drive, and I reccomend that, but there are now many cheaper alternatives. - Don't forget a tripod and/or a monopod, a flash(though it does have one, external flashes are much better), and filters if you want to experiment. Hope you enjoy your camera as much as I have! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-11-21 | | Can't get any better than this.. | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I am 67 years old and started out in photography as a kid with a contact printer and a box camera. I have had all types of cameras over the years, mostly 35mm film Canon slr's. I too bought all sorts of these 5-7 MP point and shoot digital cameras before returning to my true love, SLR's. I have had my digital Canon Rebel XT about a month now and I can't keep my hands off of it. It lacks nothing. Although the kit lense is good, I bought a 28-135 Canon zoom lense with image stabilizion and have produced stunning photo's with it. I love the way you can use the 7 points to focus, I mainly use only the center point with focus lock and never get an out of focus picture. I guess the nicest thing for me is that I now don't have the urge to buy every point and shoot camera that is paraded out on QVC or HSN that has a "wonderful" new feature like "low light or non-shake." This Canon has every good feature in the known universe and you can't outgrow it. Its a camera that will let you be as good as you can be, it won't hold you back. The battery life is great, the built in flash is good but I bought a 430EX and that's even better. I never figure I'm wasting money buying accessories for this camera as it will be my main squeeze for many years to come. I always missed my 35mm Canon slr's and now feel that I have an old friend back again, only much much better. Believe me, you can't go wrong getting this camera, its beyond description.... | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-10-07 | | Great Camera | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I have had digital cameras for about 5 years and still own an Olympus 5 megapixel, and a Casio 7 megapixel. Seems like Megamixels alone just don't cut it for me. I read about the rebel XT in a magazine and looked up the user reviews here on Amazon. I decided to go and buy one and though I am really a novice, I am extremely impressed. I have never seen such stunning quality or realistic colors from a Point & Shoot. I started with the basic settings and love the results.I am slowly progressing to more advanced settings and am getting better everyday. Even a novice who just wants stunning photography will be amazed with this camera. I also bought a Tamron 75-300 Autofocus zoom lens (look for it here on Amazon.com) and after lots of practice, have been able to take some great pictures. I have a brother in the UK who is also into digital photography, and after seeing some (full reso) photos I sent him, he rushed out and bought the XTi (called the EOS 400D across the pond)and is amazed with it. I still have a lot to learn but really cannot fault this camera. The included software is also excellent. For the record, some reviews seem to think it is too small to hold, I have big hands and don't have any problems at all. I admit though this is the first SLR I have ever owned. I will still keep a point and shoot to keep in my travel bag for spontaneous photography but I am in love with my Rebel XT!! This camera costs quite chunk of change but I think it is well worth it and I do recommend it to everyone. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-08-29 | | XT (EOS 350D) vs XTi (EOS 400D) | 8 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | After 1.5 years in the market, garnering a series of awards and praises, Digital Rebel XT (aka EOS 350D) has been replaced by Digital Rebel XTi (aka EOS 400D). For about one to two hundred dollars more, XTi offers some compelling benefits, such as: - New 3-point ultrasound dust removal system that cleans image sensor area; included software maps dust stuck in low pass area and electronically masks them. - 10.1 MP APS-C CMOS image sensor (3888 by 2592) vs. 8 MP (3456 by 2304) that improves resolution by 20% while maintaining dynamic range and noise level. - Faster image processing. In continuous shooting mode, it captures the same 3 frames per second but up to 27 JPEG or 10 RAW vs. 14 JPEG or 4 RAW. - Significantly improved 9-point TTL auto focus from EOS 30D vs. 7-point. - Brighter 2.5" 230,000 pixel LCD vs. 1.8" 115,000 pixel LCD. - Updated user interface. - Picture styles and RGB histogram. - More durable leathery paint finish. Of course, there are some losses, too. Most notably, XTi eschews dedicated LCD info display (integrated into main LCD now) and yields lower battery life (500 vs. 600 shots). All that worth extra dough? If all you want is to take great photos for less money, XT is still a great camera. I've used XT for almost a year now and it's capable of some amazing pictures, provided you use better than the crummy kit lens (although kit lens can be an affordable intro to the world of DSLR). If you can stretch your budget, XTi operates significantly faster with much nicer auto focus system. Higher resolution sensor, larger LCD with enhanced UI, and self image sensor cleaning system can be very beneficial to many as well. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 8 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-07-23 | | Great Digital SLR | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I've been using the Rebel XT for over 6 months, taken literally 1000's of pictures and it's been great. Loved my old manual 35mm Nikon SLR, have been using digital point-n-clicks but wanted the control of an SLR again--no major complaints with the Rebel XT. Overall: if you're shopping for a solid DSLR, I'd definitely recommend it. Pros: + Fast. I had a miserable time capturing action with my Canon S50 (a digital point-n-click)--response time made for hit-or-miss photos. The XT takes something like 3+ shots/second, a feature I've been happily using for action sequences I could never pull off before. + Great depth of field. This was something I really missed from the old SLRs--you just don't get much depth with point-n-clicks even in those portait modes. The XT is great for isolating subjects in the shot. + Battery lasts far longer than any other digital cameras I've had (I suspect b/c it lacks the preview window). As a bonus, the XT uses the same form factor as my Canon S50 so I only need one charger when I travel. + Auto-focus is v. fast. I know I mentioned speed before but it's worth mentioning again. I hate waiting for other digital cameras to analyze a scene and take a shot--no delays with the XT. + Starts up instantly. I didn't think I'd care about this but it's been great--you see a shot, you flick it on and before you can even raise the camera to your eye, it's ready to fire away. + Software is better than I expected--it's actually usable as compared to some other software I've received with other cameras like Kodak. Cons: - The kit lens isn't terrible but isn't great. The manual focus ring is narrow and oddly positioned right at the tip of the lens; and you have to turn-off autofocus to use it (unlike most Canon lenses you can buy). It's also noisy. Aesthetics aside, the optics are ok and the range (from wide-angle to zoom) is hard to find in other Canon lenses (I've found that I've needed separate lenses to get the same wide-angle to zoom range). - One thing I didn't fully realize when I purchased was the impact of the 1.6 cropping factor of the EF-S lens form factor. The XT can take both EF-S and EF lenses. If you throw on an EF lens (the majority of Canon EOS lenses and what I've purchased for my zoom and primes), the scene is magnified by 1.6 (or you could say the edges are cropped). As I understand it, it allows for a smaller camera. The problem is that you really can't use an EF wide-angle lens since it loses it's wide-angle--you'll need to buy an EF-S wide-angle lens and there aren't many choices (I have the 10mm-22m). My concern is that I'm not sure whether Canon will support the EF-S form factor long-term and I hate investing in lenses only to have them obsolete in a year. Will see what happens. Something to consider since you'll probably be purchasing lenses to go with this camera. - Get ready to clean the camera more. I'm admittedly rough on my equipment (used the XT in the desert and the jungle). Problem is whereas point-n-clicks are sealed and the old 35mm SLRs would simply capture dust/dirt on single frame, getting a speck on the sensor on the XT (and probably most DSLRs) causes a blob on every shot you take until you notice it during reviews and clean it. I use a hand air pump--takes seconds but just be prepared. - One final note: be wary of suntan lotion and other lotions when using Canon cameras--I've managed to rub off the decals from two camera bodies so far--the ink or whatever is used to print the icons simply disolves. I consider these minor issues given the purpose of the camera is to help you take great shots and the Rebel XT definitely does this. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-07-13 | | Outstanding purchase. | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | We purchased this camera about 2 months ago and have been nothing but pleased with its performance thus far. What you have in this Canon Rebel XT is all of the function, expandability, and speed of your standard SLR teamed with the convenience and flexibility of digital photography with Canon Quality. I don't think you can beat the quality to price ratio on this Camera - it's the sort of investment that we won't be kicking ourselves for 3 years down the road. The Pros: 1. As stated, function, expandability, and speed of an SLR built into a digital Camera. 2. The camera is built to last for quite some time - it's durable in its construction and the 8MP capability will produce super prints for years to come. 3. The battery: The life has been phenomenal so far - I don't think that I've seen the meter drop below "full," while taking photographs, and that's at taking over 400 photos at a time (not all at once though, of course). Plus, it's rechargeable - Kudos to Canon for their forward thinking 4. Speed, Speed, Speed. The camera acts just like a 35mm which means that it has a pretty fast processor. 5. Cost - a very economical choice considering what you have in this camera. The Cons: 1. Expect it to be heavy, because it is. 2. There's no built in memory. So buy a compact flash card when you buy this camera as you will need it. 3. Related to the above: A good compact flash card is not necessarily "cheap." Altogether, this camera is worth it. Buy a 1GB Compact flash and you'll be able to take more pictures at one time than most will need. [...]
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-06-07 | | Just Works | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I'd gotten away from SLRs in favor of small pocket sized digitals, but decided I wanted higher quality for blowups for my trip to Ireland. After much online research and several sessions flipping a quarter, I ordered the Canon EOS 8MP digital Rebel from Amazon. Although lugging it around Ireland for 2 weeks was something of a challenge, it exceeded my expectations from a photographic standpoint. The photos are perfect, 8X11 enlargements are crisp and detailed, the colors are true... I almost got my whole trip on one 2G CF card which beats my past experiences of coming home with 24 exposed roles of film! I use the free Picassa photo software from Google and can do pretty much everything I want to in post-production work. A couple of downers: the leather case is cumbersome to open and close and sometimes falls off when you are taking pictures; the 'battery grip' which I bought is hardly necessary--it holds two batteries but I never needed more than one during a typical day. I also had trouble trying to use fill-in flash... For the price, this is a great camera!
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-06-03 | | Excellent Camera with a Tough, Durable Body | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | A few reviewers have purchased the Canon 20D rather than the Rebel XT (350D), because the Canon 20D's body is covered with a magnesium alloy and the Rebel XT's body is mainly plastic. However, one should not discount the Rebel's plastic body. It's made of polycarbonate. I did a little research on this material and found that it is virtually unbreakable and in laminated form is used to make "bullet-resistant glass." Of course, no matter how tough the body is, something else will break, such as the lens or the internal workings, if the camera is dropped on a hard surface. That's why I always place the camera's strap around my neck before handling it. Although a couple of reviewers stated that the camera feels too light, I've found that it has plenty of heft with my 28-135mm lens. The Rebel XT is an excellent camera. My only complaint is that I tend to smudge the LCD screen when I look through the camera's view finder. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-05-26 | | Wonderful Starter DSLR | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Received the Rebel XT as a bday present and here are my impressions after a couple of weeks. Note: I had a 35mm Rebel SLR, so I did not need to purchase lenses. Pros: Granted my previous digital is a 2.1 MP point and shoot, but the Rebel is insanely fast. Near instantanous start up, and can shoot 3 shots/second. I purchased a 1 GB Sandisk high speed CF card to make sure the speed kept up. Canon's website has an extensive tuitoral about the Rebel, and from it I have found that Aperture priority (AV) mode works best in most situations. I am really a beginner with advanced modes, but have easily found setting that make the photos come out well. Other settings I have been playing with include the B/W and filter modes. The auto-focus works great in all situations I've tried. I haven't needed to recharge the battery in 2 weeks. Cons: Camera is slighly compact, which is slightly uncomfortable in large hands. I have Paint Shop Pro already, so the included software (Photobrowser, ArcSoft Photo Editor and Canon Photo Professional) are mostly useless to me, with the exception of Canon Photo being the only software I have to process RAW images. The camera is still a work in progress, as I still have a lot of paces to put it through. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-05-23 | | I really love this camera | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I've always been a fan of digital. I like the idea of previewing my photos before paying for the processing. I'm also a fan of Canon. I started with their powershot series digitals and then wanted something where I could play with lenses. I bought the first 6mp digital rebel and loved that one. Took crisp, quick photos. The only downside to that camera was it was quite heavy and it was silver (my lenses were all black). So when the XT came out I was excited. Initially I was expecting to see an improvement in performance, but when you go from 6MP to 8MP you're really not improving on the resolution (roughly the square root of the MPs). This camera still gives quick, sharp photos. Plus it's smaller and lighter than the 6mp digital rebel. I also found that the XT felt more solid and less like plastic. The setting dial is made of metal instead of plastic. I also found that the batteries seem to last for a really long time on this camera. So I don't really worry about switching out when I want to get a shot. Overall I'm really glad I purchased this camera. It was a little more than the 6mp (and if price is an issue you can easily get away with the 6mp) but I'm very happy I bought it. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-05-06 | | Not Perfect, but... | 8 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Generally speaking Canon Rebel XT/350D is a very capable camera, it's far beyond the realm of an entry-level dSLR. However, it's not without flaws, some are fairly significant. Pros: Speed, speed, and speed... Low-priced and feature-packed camera that worth every penny Excellent Burst Mode, up to 9 shots at highest JPEG resolution Compact design, solid construction, though small grip takes time to get use to User-friendly interface Great low-lighting AF capability Sharp image with vibrant color and contrast at default setting (parameter 1) Possibly best free bundled software on the market Cons: Evaluative Metering often performs poorly; Center-Weighted Average is a better choice for normal shooting No true Spot-Metering. Only Partial-Metering instead ...works ok though Auto AF point selection often misses intended target. Manual AF point selector helps but annoying to use AI Servo AF does not work well as advertised, must accompanied with high ISO and shutter speed (1/500th sec or faster) Relatively weak onboard flash, often needs positive compensation to get the job done Below average Auto White-Balance performance High ISO performance is not as good as some professional reviews. Noticeable noise at 800 and above The bottom line, Canon Rebel XT/350D is like a well-put-together high-tech toy that invites you to play every time you put your hands on. It's not camera for someone just wants to do point and shoot. To get the best of out this camera requires some learning and adequate accessory...at least one decent lens ($400 and up) and a high capacity/high speed CF card (minimum 1GB and 40x) are absolute necessities. One also must be willing to explore various options this camera provides...ISO setting, Exposure Compensation, White-Balance adjustment, Depth of Field, Creative-Zone photography and RAW shooting are just a few areas worth spending time on.
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 8 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-04-28 | | XT, the Gateway to Great Things | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Before this camera I had only used point and shoot digital and 35mm cameras. Now I can never go back, my pass-time turned into an addiction. The features, lenses, quality, and ease of use that this camera offers are astonishing. I started out just buying the 60mm macro lens and the 70-300mm zoom when I originally got this camera. Now I have more lenses and equipment than I ever thought possible. I am up to about 15,000 pictures and going strong without any problems and it just keeps getting better. If you are looking for a great camera to get you into SLR photography this is it. I am considering upgrading to the 30D soon, but I plan to keep my XT as a backup and to use with a wide angle lens while keeping the longer telephoto lens mounted on the second camera body. For the price though, you would be hard-pressed to find a better deal. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-03-28 | | Extra Info *** | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | If it where weather sealed (dust), it would be Pro Quality! With the included software, you can connect this camera with your PC and shoot photo's directly to your PC. I used two 5ft USB extection cables along with the included USB cable, and had no trouble shooting 81 photo's so far. Initial battery charge lasted 76 RAW shots @ 96% flash usage. (stock flash & 18-55mm kit lense). Opteka Battery Pack Grip is a good option at half the street price of Canons Battery Grip (same product). The kit lense is worth the small price, if you'll ever get into a dusty situation that you wouldn't want to use a more expensive lense in. (In my opinion.) RAW images have averaged 6.44MB, and (for example) one image saved as RAW + JPEG == 6.88MB RAW and 6.45MB jpg === 13.33MB total. (This is just one image example, but it gives you an idea of what memory cards to get -> 1-2GB) Type II Compact Flash is the reccomended memory card. Anything faster will not improve camera speed... only "download to PC speed". Self timer is 10 seconds, and I cannot change it to 2 seconds, although you can change setting to "Mirror Lockup: On" which will then give a "2 second delay" while using the self timer function. Adorama Camera shipped my Canon Rebel XT w/ kit lense FASTER than Amazon shipped my 75-300mm USM lense. Don't be affraid to order from them though Amazon. I almost was, but am glad I did. That's why I shot direct to my PC... waiting for memory card, lense, hood, and Cannon UV Haze Filter. Read the manual. I LOVE this camera!!! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-03-11 | | Budget dSLR - Great for beginners | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | This is my first SLR of any type and it was an excellent purchase. I bought my Rebel XT approx. six months ago and I'm still learning new things everyday. I've since purchased the 430EX flash, Sigma 18-200, Tomron 28-300 lens, Kinko 2X extender (cheap lens), Battery Grip, and a second battery. I love the manual settings for low-light work and taking several servo speed shots. I'm not familiar yet with taking RAW photo shots instead of JPEG, but I'm still researching this. I thought I would want the teleophoto lens most, but now I realize I'm more interested in the wide lens and I'm seriously looking at the Sigma 10-20mm lens. I still like the telephoto lens for the long distance shots, but I find I'm taking more photos either indoors or of large buildings and monuments where I want to get the whole object in the picture without being far away (where more obstacles block a clear sight). Essential gear is probably a large memory card!! I found an Ultra II 2GB CF card for $85 on another website - I had purchased about three 512MB cards and now I don't have to switch out so much for the high JPEG setting. A Tripod is needed for any serious telephoto, low-light, or any shot with long shutter speed. The battery grip is needed for those that think the camera is too small or want to at least look like a pro. I know I'm a rookie, but I love walking around Europe snapping shots anywhere I can. This camera has certainly peaked my interest in the other "full-frame" dSLR cameras, but I probably won't spend too much more money unless I can make some money with it. Hope this helps!! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-01-20 | | What an amazing camera!!! Also: Comparison b/w NIKON D70 and Rebel XT. | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I've been using this camera for a few months now and I can't say anything but praise. I've transitioned from using point and shoot cameras to the SLR. I just can't believe the difference. The quality of the photos is truly amazing. I was actually debating between the Nikon D70 and the XT. I had been preferring the D70 b/c of the "better" kit lens. But I actually went to Best Buy and took pictures with both cameras, side by side, at different settings including full auto. I then printed out prints to compare the two. The XT was ablt to pick up small shows and detail in the back of the store that the D70 just showed as a blur. All different settings looked better with the XT. The pictures were much, much clearer and crisper and the color was much more like actual colors in the store. Also, the D70 wasn't as easy to use as the XT. The menus were not as clear as the XT. Needless to say, I stopped looking into the D70. Now, over 7500 photos later, I'm totally happy with my choice. I have actually zoomed in on portraits using my desktop and was able to see the tear ducts in my daughter's eyes. The camera is also simple enough for my wife to take great photos. Pros: 3 pics per second - super fast. Great price for a dig SLR. Easy to use menus. Great indoor photos. Battery charges in less than 2 hrs and lasts forever. Many great Canon lenses to choose from. Manual and auto focus lens is great. Great clarity photos. 8 megapixal is awesome. Prints great 8x10's. (I also just got the Canon MP500 printer AIO. Only 150 w/ free S/H) Cons: only uses CF media (and doesn't come w/ a card) - I like CF though b/c you can buy the larger CF type 2 cards - I got the 6GB card - can take about 1500 pics on highest quality. SD or other types of media are more limited on size of cards. Overall - GREAT Camera. I totally recommend for regular home use or professional use. Great price. Can't go wrong with this one. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-01-18 | | Handles Great, Autofocus just not there | 6 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | First, a couple of things. I wanted this camera to be great. I researched all the consumer dSLRs and decided on the XT Rebel 350 because of it's size and 8MP CCD, plus, I'd had two Canon point and shoot digitals that were fantastic. I've been taking pictures on a semi-professtional level for thirty years and I attended Brooks Institute of Photography, so I sort of know what I'm doing. Bought the Rebel XT at a local store in San Francisco, along with the Canon 28-200 Zoom. Immediately went up to Chinatown to shoot pictures of the Festival of the Harvest Moon with my wife, who was using her Nikon D70 with the Nikon 28-200. Shot pictures all day, and absolutely loved the way the XT handled. It was very intuitive, fast, had a bright viewfinder -- I couldn't have been happier. Then, we got home and looked at the pictures. I'd shot mostly on automatic, or shutter priority all day, with shutter speeds above 250th of a second. Bottom line, my wife's pictures were crystal clear, popped really, and mine of the same or similar subjects were just a tad fuzzy. You couldn't tell at 5x7 or so, but when you brought it up to 8x10 or above the difference was obvious. I checked the historgram on the shots, and they were made at nearly the same settings. Couldn't be, right? After all, the Nikon is only 6 MP, the Canon 8MP. So I put both cameras on a tripod, pointed them at a brick wall with a sign about 100 feet away, set everything the same on the cameras, and low and behold, same fuzziness. I took the Canon back the next day and traded it in on a D70. Now, maybe I got a bad lense, or a camera where the auto-focus was tweaked, but I couldn't afford the time to test it out again and again. I knew the Nikon would work, and it did (and does). Since then, I've talked to friends, professionals, who say that the XT is known to have auto-focus "issues". This seems to be inconsistent, with some reviewers being delighted by the camera, others having a little problem. As I said above, the camera handles really well, intuitively, and I actually like the compact size (some SLR users like a heavier camera). I may have gotten a lemon, but if you are going to need to depend on getting sharp pictures and can't go back for reshoots, I'd step up to the Canon D20 or go with a Nikon dSLR. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 6 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-01-02 | | Best Digital Camera for the money | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Read every review I could find while searching for a new DSLR. Decided the Canon Rebel XT was the best for the money. It has all the important features a serious amateur would want and then some. Well, I received the camera over a week ago and I can't believe how good this camera is. Been a long time 35mm SLR user and a Digicam user since 2001. This camera is the closest to film you will get for the price and with all the advantages digital has to offer (technically speaking, a DSLR would have to be 12 megapixels to exactly match 35mm film quality). My only reservation is it's small size but that is a very minor complaint. A friend of mine has a Canon 20D and it is a better camera, but only slightly and costs $500.00 more. Save your money or spend it on a better lens, I bought the Canon EFS 17-85mm and it performs beautifully. By the way, don't believe all the critics that say megapixels aren't important and 6 megapixels are enough - that is not true. Even though most people are not printing large 8X10 or larger prints, many photos are indeed cropped and the more megapixel per photo there is the sharper the photo will remain. This is one area Canon seems to beat all of its competitors in this price range. | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2006-01-01 | | $100 tip learned the hard way | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | I can't say enough about this camera. I won't launch into superlatives you can read in all the other reviews other than to agree that it is the best thing this amateur has ever bought. If the XT is going to someone that will only use it 5-10 times a year, the kit lens is fine. My advice for those like me that are trying to step up into taking photographs rather than pictures? Buy the camera as a body only, spend 80ish dollars on the 50mm 1.8 prime lens, and another 20ish on the remote. You will still come out cheaper than if you buy the XT with a kit lens AND have an amazing, fast lens that gets raving reviews on Amazon and elsewhere. Check the lens reviews for yourself, especially if you're not familiar with prime vs. zoom lenses. The tiny remote is handy too! I'm betting you will eventually buy at least one more lens than what you start with to explore the capabilities of the XT. This is true whether you start out with the kit or the 1.8. I use the 28-135 IS and the 1.8. The kit lens is in a box in my garage somewhere, so I could have saved myself $100 if someone had suggested to me what I am to you.
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2005-12-18 | | Great but Not Perfect. 4.5 Stars. | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | After a long and detailed due diligence on a mid-level professional digital cameras, my search ended between Nikon (D70/D50) and Canon (20D/350D). I finally decided on 350D for its balance of a great value and a huge variety of after-market accessories and web-based support and advice. I recently received this camera from Amazon and, though my expectation was rather high and the camera did not blow me away, I'm very happy with the purchase. PROS: - Light, compact, and ergonomically designed. - The camera does NOT feel plasticky at all. It feels solid and radiates the craftsmanship of a prosumer product. - Easy to use. Take the camera out of the box and start snapping away. - The bundled software is useful if not professional quality. - Amazing flash performance. Pictures taken in total dark comes out looking professionally lit. - Quiet when snapping pictures. Fast startup time. Very good batter life. - For a fan of Canon, add to the inventory of other Canon products, from camera to lenses to printers to photo paper. CONS: - The EF-S zoom lens that comes with it is rather slow and a bit disappointing in picture quality. - The camera - as many reviewers complained - is ergonomic but does not feel very well balanced. It's very awkward to take a picture with only one hand holding the camera - you need two hands. No matter how I tried, my grip on the camera never feels comfortable. - Documentation is buggy and uneven. Some of the step-by-step instructions simply do not work, and I had to figure out the correct steps by playing with the controls myself. (...)Amazon double-boxed the package, which arrived without a dent.
| Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | | | Amazon.com customer | 2005-12-15 | | Capable of very good results | 10 | NR | NR | NR | NR | | | | Helpful? | Background: began photography in 1979 using a K1000 developing in the school darkroom. I've used a T90 since they were introduced in 1986, added a Hasselblad in 1999 for landscapes and a Sony point and shoot in 2002 for "walking around". I found I was using the Sony for all our holiday and travel shots, and the Hasselblad just for my recreational landscapes, the T90 not at all. I began to want the creative control I had with 35mm but with the convenience of digital, and decided that a DSLR was the answer. Here's how I use my Rebel XT: With a 24mm EOS as the ultimate "carry around" camera, it's very compact and light, has outstanding battery life and gets plenty of shots on a 1Gig card. Perfect for "point and click" type shooting. Switch to the outstanding 17-40 f4L and add the battery grip for more "serious" out and about shooting. This is my typical vacation configuration. The battery grip provides a very comfortable holding position, and I can probably manage over 1,000 shots without recharging when using two batteries. The 17-40 f4L is a beautiful lens with outstanding color rendition and resolving power, it also has very good environmental seals that keep moisture out of the lens and the body. I've had the surface of an umbrella in Scotland dumped on the camera in this configuration and it survived fine. For motorsports photography I use the 70-200 f4L and a monopod. I've had prints made at 24"x36" from these sessions that are simply stunning. For closeups I use a set of fully automatic tubes and a 50mm 1.8, a great lens for very little money. Observations: Be prepared to do more work in post-processing than with a point and shoot, the Rebel XT does not pump up the colors or sharpening as much in camera as the strictly "consumer" cameras - but used properly the results can be much better. Control focus points yourself. I think many focus problems stem either from not noticing that the camera has picked the wrong point for you, or not paying attention to the aperture picked if using one of the more "programmed" modes. I use Speed priority or Aperture priority only, just as I always did with the T90. I tend to configure auto focus so that only the centre sensor is used and use focus hold to pick the spot and then re-frame. I initially had some disappointing results until I took more control of the process myself. Above all enjoy! | Satisfaction | Score |
|---|
| Overall satisfaction | 10 |
|
| | | | | | |
| |